Saturday, May 18, 2019
Ethics of War based on religion Essay
If you ask anyone, they result give you their opinion, their cypher on state of war. Whether they believe its right hand, its wrong, or if they think it is all based on the business office at hand. Wars live with been going on since the beginning and they be still going on today, but are they macrocosm fought for a purpose? Are they universe fought due to a locating that has arisen? This assay will prove two ethical frameworks and how they apply to the same issue. The ethical issue that will be discussed throughout this essay is that of War, and the frameworks that surround it are Situation Ethics and the Duty-Based Ethics.Situation morals is when a choice is make based on the circumstances at hand. In situation morals there is no right or wrong answer as each circumstance has variant outcomes. Situation ethics rejects prefabricated decisions and prescriptive rules. It teaches that ethical decisions should follow flexible guidelines rather than absolute rules, and be t aken on a effort by case basis. This ethical framework provides so much discussion as each situation that evolves will have a reaction, and the challenge is to choose the least prostituteful or problematic pick it all depends on the situation. The situation ethics surrounding war is if its right to fight against a country. There was recently a situation whether or not it was right for the USA to invade Syria for utilise chemical weapons. The outcome was that the USA did not end up going to war, as it would cause much(prenominal) damage then what has already go oned. AlthoughBarack Obama, the president of the USA, did apprehend the chemical weapons so cases like this did not happen again.Duty-based ethics is when someone does the right affair even though it may cause more harm then good. There are tribe out there who criticize men and women from the defence forces for being killers, but this is not the case, these men and women put their lives on the line so they layabout fi ght for freedom, for those who cant. Duty-based ethics teaches that some acts are right or wrong because of the sorts of things they are, and people have a vocation to act accordingly, regardless of the good or bad consequences that may be produced. Some kinds of action are wrong or right in themselves, regardless of the consequences.. A soldier would have to face duty-based ethics on a regular bases throughout a war, as it is their job to fight and protect people against harm. Ben Roberts-Smith is a prime example, as he put himself on the line by drawing out-of-door the enemy, just so the rest of his unit would survive. That is just one example of many different types of duty-based ethics that would be faced throughout a war.Although situation ethics and duty-based ethics are quite different they both apply to the ethical issue of war. Each framework discussed in the essay applies to war, but situation ethics seems to be the weaker of the two as it is based on what the person thi nks the best outcome will be in that situation rather then, duty-based ethics which is what the right thing is to do at that implication in time. Duty-based ethics is definitely the one that relates best to the issue of war, as it is a soldiers job to do what is right, at the moment the issue arises.Throughout this essay the ethical issue of war was discussed based on the ethical frameworks that surround it, which are situation ethics and duty-based ethics. The framework that proves to be the more applicable comparison to the issue of war is duty-based ethics, because they are decisions made based on the right thing to do.BibliographyBBC. Duty-Based Ethics. BBC News. BBC, n.d. Web. 14 Mar. 2014. .BBC. Situation Ethics. BBC News. BBC, n.d. Web. 14 Mar. 2014. .Whittaker, Matt. Soldier in Afghanistan. 2011. Afghanistan. Http//static.guim.co.uk/. Web. 14 Mar. 2014. .